Remember your MySpace Top 8? You could have a thousand friends on that profile. The Top 8 were the ones who mattered, the people you'd move around at 2 a.m. depending on who you were mad at that week. Everyone who visited your profile looked at who made the Top 8.
Your website works the same way. More traffic is not the goal for a service business, since visitors only count if they could hire you. In 12+ years and 100+ sites worked on, I've learned that a site with fewer visitors who fit your offer will bring in more clients than a site full of people who were never going to hire you.
The Short Answer
More traffic is not the goal because visitors only matter if they could become clients. A smaller audience of the right people brings in more inquiries than a big audience of the wrong ones. Focus on fit: who your site attracts, whether they match your offer and whether they take the next step.
If You're Reading This Because It's Your Site
Reading more isn't the hard part. La Jugada is $47 and it tells you which layer this is actually sitting in.
Get it, $47Why Is More Traffic Not the Goal?
Traffic is a count of visits, the kind of number Nielsen Norman Group calls a vanity metric, one that looks impressive without telling you how the site is really performing. It goes up, the chart looks great and it seems like progress. Ay, mija, a chart can look great while your inbox stays quiet.
Every visitor who isn't a fit still costs you something. They'll take up space in your analytics, they make your conversion rate look worse and they can make you think the site is broken when it's attracting the wrong crowd. If you write or post to chase volume, you end up with blog posts that bring traffic and no clients, read by people who like the content and have no reason to buy.
I've seen it work the other way too. A client stopped chasing a keyword that brought traffic and no buyers. Their traffic dropped and the leads that came in got better.
The real goal is inquiries and bookings from people you can help, which is what website success actually looks like. Traffic's only useful as a way to get there.
What Does the Right Traffic Look Like?
The right visitors share a few things. They've got the problem you solve and they're the kind of business you work with. They can afford what you offer now or they will soon. And when they land on your site, they recognize themselves in what your website says about your business.
That last part is where your site does the work. When your copy says who you help and what changes for them, the right people stay and the wrong ones move on, which is what you want. Eso sí, it only works if the site is specific, which is why clarity beats adding more content. "We help businesses grow" fits everyone, so it attracts everyone.
I keep coming back to one question I ask about social media too: do you know who your people are? If you can't describe them, your site won't attract them on purpose. If your copy speaks to everyone, your website may be losing you clients without you noticing.
How Do You Know Whether You Have the Right Traffic?
Look past the total and check three things:
- Where visitors come from. Search terms from Search Console's Performance report, referral sites and social posts tell you what brought people in. Ojo, if the searches have nothing to do with your offer, the traffic won't either.
- What they do next. The right visitors read your services page, check out your about page and reach out. You'll see it in the path. The wrong ones bounce off a single blog post.
- Who inquires. If inquiries come in and they're not a fit, your site is attracting the wrong people. If good-fit people inquire, the traffic's working even if the number's small.
Fit shows up fastest in your referrals. In my work, referred leads close faster and with less convincing than any other source. They arrive already knowing you're a match. That's what the right traffic does for you before anyone fills out a form.
The website metrics that matter walks through how to track all three. If your traffic is climbing and your revenue isn't, start with traffic is up but revenue is not. The right visitors over more visitors is a theme that runs through all my website strategy.
How Do You Attract More of the Right People?
Say who it's for. Name your audience on your homepage and service pages. Nena, it's the fastest way to filter for fit.
Write content for your clients. Answer the questions your clients ask before they hire you. That fits what Google calls helpful, people-first content, content created primarily for people. A post about a problem your clients have will draw fewer readers than a viral topic and far better ones.
Send social traffic to the right pages. Link posts to the page that matches what people just saw. How the two should work together lives in website vs social media.
Treat the site like something you own. The people you attract on your site are yours to keep through an email list or a booking. That's the idea behind treating your website like a business asset.
It can feel scary to aim for fewer people, diache. But nobody ever scrolled your thousand friends. They checked your Top 8.
What to Do This Week
- Write one sentence describing your ideal client. Check whether your homepage says it.
- Look at last month's top search terms or referral sources. Mark which ones match your offer.
- List the last five inquiries. Note which were a good fit and where they came from.
- Pick one page to make more specific. Name who it's for in the first few lines.
Key Takeaways
- More traffic is not the goal. Aim for visitors who could become clients.
- Wrong-fit traffic makes your numbers look worse and can pull you toward the wrong content.
- Check where visitors come from, what they do next and who inquires.
- Attract the right people by naming who you help, writing for your clients and sending traffic to matching pages.
Okay, so is my site even reaching the right people?
Before you chase more visitors, La Digital Rueda shows you where the pressure is. It asks a few questions about your site, your content and your backend and takes about two minutes. It's free.
Want more like this in your inbox? Off the Clock is my week-ish newsletter about websites, systems and burnout-free business.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is more website traffic always better?
No. Traffic only helps if the visitors could become clients. A large audience that doesn't match your offer can lower your conversion rate and send you chasing the wrong content. For a service business, a smaller group of good-fit visitors can bring in more inquiries than a big crowd of the wrong people.
What matters more than website traffic?
Inquiries and bookings from people you can help. Watch where your visitors come from, what they do on your site and whether the people who reach out are a good fit. Those tell you whether your site is working far better than a total visitor count.
How do I get the right visitors to my website?
Say clearly who you help on your homepage and service pages. Write content that answers questions your clients ask before they hire you. Send social traffic to pages that match what people just saw. The clearer your site is about who it's for, the more the right people stay.
Why do I get traffic but no inquiries?
Either the traffic isn't a fit or the site isn't turning good-fit visitors into inquiries. Check the search terms and sources that bring people in, then look at which pages they leave from. The answer tells you whether to change who you attract or fix the path to your offer.
Does low traffic mean my website is failing?
Not necessarily. A site with modest traffic can bring in steady clients if the visitors fit your offer and the path to inquire is clear. Judge your site by the inquiries and clients it produces, then work on growing the right kind of traffic over time.
About the Author
